The Great Silmarillion Read Along

This announcement is a full month early, but I’m too excited not to post it at the end of my Tolkien birthday month celebration, so here we are!

Excited exciting happy GIF - Find on GIFER

A couple years ago, I finally read The Silmarillion by JRR Tolkien, and it was an experience. Honestly, though my reviews have continued to be chaotic and weird for Middle-earth, that first one was where it really started, and I’ll forever hold it warmly in my thoughts. And though it might seem like a really wacky way to review something as esteemed as Tolkien, the language in there is how I talk about a lot of things. It’s how I write my outlines–I will forever find this line in a third book outline hilarious: does anyone die? we’ll circle back–it’s how I describe movies to friends, it’s how I talk in general. And so, it doesn’t really surprise me that, when it came time to review one of the most convoluted stories by my favorite author, that my insane side came out.

But then, something started to happen. Friends that had always been nervous of The Silmarillion laughed over the post and started to think about maybe reading it on their own since I’d made it seem so fun. My dad finally had a moment of oh, maybe I shouldn’t have completely disregarded it. Comments came in of how much more accessible the book felt. And I continued on my merry way, reviewing every Tolkien book that I could find, until, at long last, I came to the end of the trilogy.

This GIF really shows their individual personalities | Fellowship of the  ring, Lord of the rings, The hobbit

I read the trilogy over a decade ago for the first time, and then, weirdly, never again since. But reading it again now, as an adult, and particularly after the wonder that was The Silmarillion, has made me love it even more. There is so much lore packed into LOTR that’s easily missed without the backbone of the rest of Tolkien’s work, and every time a new piece of lore would pop up, I’d sigh wistfully about that summer two years ago when I finally cracked open what may be my favorite Tolkien book ever.

As always, while reading, I was inundating my friends with random Tolkien facts and Middle-earth lore, and the more I told them, the more they wanted to know until, finally, one of my friends said, “You should write a full Silmarillion readalong. Like the first one, but expand it even more, almost like a guide.”

And look, I know they exist out there, but I also know they don’t quite exist in my style, which is full of “BUT IT WAS GAY” comments, overflowing with fanart, and just general screaming before full length paragraphs of lore breakdown. Thus, The Silmarillion month-long readalong was born.

lord of the rings LOTR The Return of The King merry and pippin my  stuff:movies riddleyscott •

Why am I only using gifs of hobbits? Well, because, of course, that there are no hobbits in The Silmarillion, and it’s really sad! I understand why not, and I’m fully ready to scream into the abyss about elves again, but yeah, I’m going to miss these little rascals.

So, here’s the plan. I’m going to reread The Silmarillion in February, but I’m going to break it into four parts that are going to be posted weekly in March. The Society celebrates Tolkien month in March, so it’ll be a fun addendum to whatever plans you’ve already got going on! I’m going to post them whether or not anyone is reading along with me because I’m going to have too much fun rereading it, and I’ll need an outlet, so really, these would happen with or without a readalong. But, if you’ve always been itching to read The Silmarillion, or if you want to reread it because you didn’t quite get it all the first time, or if you’re just excited about the stories and want to shout with me, this is for you!

Each Friday, a new post will go up with everything for the week following. Thus, on 2/26, you’ll get a breakdown for whatever we’ll be reading for the first week of March. They’ll probably be broken up into about 100 pages or so for each week, given that it’s around 400 pages long. Each section (and subsection) will have breakdowns dedicated, including who the characters are, what the heck is going on, and um, you know, probably several lengthy dissertations about any of the following: Morgoth, Fingolfin, Maedhros, Beleg, Lúthien.

So, what say you?
Will you journey into the first ages of Middle-earth with me?

Obviously, as most of the art is going to be for the month of March, the featured image is by Phobs, and WOW it’s fitting.

Posted by

she/her | yoga teacher | Tibetan Buddhism | part-time witch | full-time author | astronaut in a previous life

15 thoughts on “The Great Silmarillion Read Along

  1. I do love The Silmarillion, but I’m going to pass on this, as I have so much already on my plate for February. But happy reading!

    You should check out The Prancing Pony podcast, which had an entire season devoted to The Silmarillion. The hosts, Alan and Shawn, are hilarious.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I totally get that! I’m reading it in February so I’ve got everything all set for March and don’t have to worry about it at all. And still have to fit in the History of Middle-earth volumes somewhere!

      Liked by 2 people

  2. This just came at the perfect time. I read the hobbit + the trilogy for the first time last year after years of loving the movies but being too intimidated to pick up the books. The way you talk about Tolkien has definitely influenced that decision and made me feel like his writing might be way more accessible than what I had originally thought. So I got the Silmarillion recently and have been planning on reading it this year.
    All that to say, I’ll definitely be joining the read-a-long! I’m so excited to be back in this amazing world ❤︎

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Oh my gosh, YAY! This is just the best comment ever! I’m just so stupidly excited right now. I can’t wait to start writing the weekly posts, and I feel like this’ll be a March to remember. ❤ I'm so glad you're joining in!

      Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s